Last week I got an email from Zack from the 185 Miles South podcast asking for nominations for their year-end lists… is it really that time already? Normally I start a “best of the year” playlist at the beginning of the year and drop in things I like as I hear them. The beginning of this year was a rough time, though, and I never got around to it. So I spent a little time this weekend going through past editions of the newsletter and the new arrivals stack at my house, building my playlist from scratch. I ended up with a shortlist of 23 releases. From here I’ll listen to the playlist on album shuffle for the next couple months and let everything soak in more deeply. Some things will drop off as I listen to them more and recency bias fades, and no doubt things will get added as they’re released and/or I hear about them. Right now, the leading candidate for album of the year is the new Kohti Tuhoa LP. I realize few of you have heard it yet, but I’ve had it for a few months, and I still can’t stop spinning it. It’s one of those records that gets better every time you play it. If you have any recommendations for things you think I might like but might not be on my radar, please send ‘em along!
As for my staff pick this week, I’m writing about yet another Siouxsie and the Banshees record. Back in January I chose The Thorn EP as my staff pick, and shortly after sending out that newsletter my buddy Ben (aka Bedge) wrote to give me his pick for under-the-radar Banshees banger. It took me a few months to find a copy, but it’s my staff pick for this week:
Siouxsie and the Bansheees: Song from the Edge of the World 12” (Geffen, 1987)
(Speaking of Ben, I want to note he just published his second book! It’s called Beastie Boys: Licensed to Ill: 40 Years and it looks absolutely stunning. Here’s the book’s page on the publisher’s website, which has a bunch of page previews and links to buy the book from several online bookstores.)
“Song from the Edge of the World” came out in 1987, which was a transitional time for the Banshees. They were coming off the artistic triumph that was 1986’s Tinderbox, which I think is neck-and-neck with Juju as the Banshees’ best album. However, after that high, the band must have been on the rocks creatively. Alongside “Song from the Edge of the World,” 1987 also saw the release of the covers album Through the Looking Glass. Covers albums can be fun, but they’re not a sign a band is at a creative peak. Indeed, guitarist John Valentine Carruthers was soon out of the band, with new members Martin McCarrick (keyboards) and Jon Klein (guitar) joining for “Song from the Edge of the World” and 1988’s Peepshow, the latter of which overhauled the band’s sound and gave them their biggest US single with “Peek-A-Boo.”
“Song from the Edge of the World” straddles the Carruthers and McCarrick/Klein eras, having made its live debut in 1986, demoed during the sessions for Tinderbox, and recorded once again for a January 1987 BBC session for Janice Long’s show. Carruthers plays on these two earlier versions, while McCarrick and Klein play on the two versions released as singles. Despite being credited to the newly revamped lineup, the song sounds more of a piece with the lush, dreamy sound of Tinderbox. Indeed, while there are obvious differences between the four studio versions of “Song from the Edge of the World,” the instrumentation and mood of the track changed little across its several iterations.
When I wrote about The Thorn for my previous staff pick, I noted that it’s the only EP the Banshees released in their two-plus decade run. The version of “Song from the Edge of the World” I have is a 45rpm 12” with four tracks, but it’s classified as a “maxi-single,” perhaps because two of those tracks are versions of the same song. Or maybe it’s because the US vinyl release combines all the tracks from the different versions of the single released in the UK and Europe. The 7” of “Song from the Edge of the World” (which was available in both picture sleeve and picture disc versions) featured a mix clocking in at 3 minutes, 43 seconds and the b-side “The Whole Price of Blood.” However, if you bought the 12” version, the version of “Song from the Edge of the World” you got was 7 minutes, 34 seconds, with “Mechanical Eyes” appended as a second b-side track. Confused? Well, you don’t have to be, because thankfully the US maxi-single version features both mixes of “Song from the Edge of the World” and both b-sides. It’s one of the few cases I can think of where there are several internationally released versions of a record, and the US one is the most comprehensive and offers the best value for money. America, fuck yeah!
I read somewhere that the Banshees disowned “Song from the Edge of the World” shortly after its release because they weren’t satisfied with any of the versions. While the song had a video (albeit a low-budget-looking one), it didn’t appear on Twice Upon a Time, the compilation of singles from the latter half of the Banshees career, despite being a stand-alone, non-album single. Of course I don’t know what the band was expecting based on what they were hearing in their heads, but I think the 3:43 7” mix of the song is brilliant, on the same level as _Tinderbox_’s singles “Cities in Dust” and “Candyman.” I love the sparkling harpsichord (I think?) melody in the verses, and the chorus soars, with one of the band’s broadest and most memorable melodies: “over we go / diving for pearls / over we go / from the edge of the world.”
As for the 7:34 12” mix (dubbed the “Columbus Mix” on the US maxi-single), I can see why the band wasn’t happy with that. It’s odd, and frankly a bit amateurish-sounding in places. While the mix is double the length of the 7” version, it doesn’t get into the trance-y, dance-y groove you might expect from a 12” club mix (not that this is billed at one). Instead, the song works through several cycles of crescendo and decrescendo (including two separate drum breaks!). The drums are where this 12” mix really shines. This mix gives a lot of extra space to Budgie’s drumming, and if you’re a fan of dense polyrhythms, it’s a show-stopper. It’s wild that Budgie recorded all these vastly different passes of the song’s main rhythm, and it makes me wonder how much other Budgie brilliance they left on the cutting room floor.
As for the b-sides, they’re alright, but not essential. I’ve remarked before how the Banshees were really good at evaluating their work. In general, their singles are their best songs, the album tracks are weaker, and the B-sides are weaker than that. Their B-sides often feel like failed or at least incomplete experiments. That’s the case with “The Whole Price of Blood,” which actually repurposes drum and sitar tracks from the song “Swimming Horses,” which appeared on 1984’s Hyaena (Robert Smith was in the band at that point, and he’s the one playing sitar). The song is very percussion-heavy (including some tuned percussion), which makes it sound like Siouxsie and Budgie’s side project the Creatures. “Mechanical Eyes” is similarly rhythm-focused, though the drum machine and synth bass give early 80s electro vibes… it almost like something that might have been sampled for an early hip-hop track. Both b-sides have interesting elements, but they don’t come together as songs the way the Banshees’ best tracks do.
So yeah, that’s “Song from the Edge of the World.” I agree with Ben that it’s one of the great under-appreciated Banshees tracks, and I feel enriched by having spent time with it for the past few weeks. If you’re interested in picking up a copy, I’m pleased to tell you the superior US version is a fairly cheap record. If you’re patient, you can find a nice copy for 10−15, or if you’re impatient, you can pick up a less-than-perfect copy for that price or a nice copy for only slightly more. If you just want the banger track, you can track down the UK 7” version, or get it as a bonus track on the expanded edition of Through the Looking Glass (where it is, oddly, the only song that isn’t a cover). And if you love the song and want to get really into the weeds, you can also hear the original studio demo with John Valentine Carruthers on the expanded edition of Tinderbox and the Janice Long session version in the Siouxsie and the Banshees: At the BBC box set.